First look at SUSE on the HP Mini-Note

After using SUSE on the HP Mini-Note for much of the afternoon, I’m convinced that the operating system provides pretty much everything most people will need in a laptop experience. I was able to configure and setup my system in about 15 minutes, and get online in just a few more. The computer does a pretty good job of finding and connecting to available internet connections. And it has a full suite of productivity software including Firefox, Evolution, and OpenOffice.org.

In the video above, I try to give an overview of the software included with the SUSE version of the Mini-Note, and how the computer performs. I apologize for the poor video quality. I was using my Eee PC webcam to record the video, since my digital camera can only record about 180 seconds of video at a time.

A few other quick notes.

  1. The battery charges quickly. Within about an hour of plugging the computer in, the battery was fully charged, even though it was running for most of that time. Compare that to an Eee PC battery which takes a few hours to charge fully — when the computer is turned off.
  2. I’m a bit disappointed to see that the AC adapter has 3 prongs. This makes the Mini-Note slightly less portable, since it’s often difficult to find a 3 prong power strip at coffee shops and libraries. I might have to spring for an extended battery since the Mini-Note reportedly only gets 2 to 2.5 hours of battery life from a standard battery.

For my next trick, I plan to install Windows XP. Personally I’m just more comfortable with the operating system, and since I write about Windows and Linux software for a living what I really want is a dual boot system, and that usually means wiping any existing operating systems and installing Windows XP first and then another OS. I’ll probably try to get Ubuntu up and running, since that’s one of the most popular distros these days, and it’s the one I have the most experience with. But I’m relatively impressed with SUSE and I may return to it.

Update: As several people have pointed out, the Mini-Note comes with SUSE Enterprise Linux, not OpenSUSE. So just ignore me when I say OpenSUSE in the video, and I’ve changed the text of this article a bit. Thanks for keeping me on my toes!

Friday, April 25th, 2008 | Tags: , , , ,

Mini-Note first impressions

I’ve had my HP Mini-Note for a few hours now, and while I’m not ready to write up a complete an thorough review, I thought I’d share a few thoughts.

I purchased the $549 model which has a 1.2GHz processor, 120GB hard drive, and runs OpenSUSE. The first time you boot up the computer, it takes 10 or 15 minutes to configure your OpenSUSE installation before you can use the PC. After that, it takes about a minute and a half to boot up. This is comparable to the length of time it takes to boot my Eee PC 701 running eeeXubuntu.

Now, keep in mind, I have eeeXubuntu installed on an SD card, which means I need to hit F2 during startup, select my boot device, navigate GRUB, and then enter my username and password before I get to a working desktop. And the Eee PC still won the race by a few seconds. I have Windows XP installed on the device’s main memory, and it boots in about half the time. So the Mini-Note running OpenSUSE is no speed demon when it comes to boot times.

Once my computer was configured, my next goal was to get it online. The Ethernet connection worked immediately. WiFi was a bit trickier. While the Mini-Note automatically recognized my router, my router didn’t recognize the Mini-Note. Since I use a MAC access list to limit access to our home internet connection, it took me a moment to plot my next move. Fortunately, I realized that I could enter my MAC address by hand. So after 15 minutes of setup, and 2 minutes of trying to figure out how to connect to the internet, my Mini-Note was up, running, and online.

One thing I should note here is that the 1280 x 768 pixel display is amazingly crisp. My primary laptop has a 1280 x 800 display. But it’s on a 15.4 inch screen, while the Mini-Note has an 8.9 inch screen. I’m seriously thinking I might need to use a lower resolution for some day to day tasks to prevent eye strain. Or I might see if I can increase some font sizes instead. Overall, this is a pleasant problem to have. My biggest complaint with the Asus Eee PC is that it’s small screen and low resolution make it difficult to fit large windows on the screen. No such problem with the Mini-Note.

OpenSUSE has the Firefox web browser and OpenOffice.org installed by default. Since I use these same applications on a day to day basis on my Windows and Ubuntu machines, I felt right at home. If all you need to do is browse the web, write and edit documents, OpenSUSE should do the trick. But I found the operating system a bit offputting once I dug a little deeper. It’s not immediately clear to me how to do things like write files to an external hard drive. When I plugged in a USB hard drive so I could backup my default settings, I was told I didn’t have write permission for that drive. So I logged off and logged back in as Root, and I still didn’t have permission.

I’m fairly certain that I could figure out how to live with OpenSUSE, but since I write about Windows and Linux software for a living, I really want to be able to run Windows on this computer. So my next step will be installing Windows XP. It looks like HP did include a 400MB system restore partition on the Linux version of the Mini-Note, so I’m hoping I can restore OpenSUSE if I want later. But Windows can be pretty picky about which partitions it runs on, so I might wind up losing my restore partition. If that happens, I’ll just learn to live with the consequences — at least until HP gets around to offering a restore disc or any other kind of support for the OpenSUSE model on its web site.

Before I do the XP thing though, I’m going to shoot a little video walkthrough of OpenSUSE on the Mini-Note. So stay tuned for that…

Friday, April 25th, 2008 | Tags: , , , , ,

HP 2133 Mini-Note Linux version might not be such a great deal

The HP 2133 Mini-Note comes in a variety of configurations, but the cheapest version running Windows Vista starts at $599, while you can pick up a version running OpenSUSE Linux for $499 or $549. But to date, every review I’ve seen on the web has looked at the Vista unit.

I ordered an OpenSUSE model which should hopefully arrive this weekend. But after reading the comments of one Notebook Review forum member who has already received his, I’m starting to get a little worried.

He says he’s experienced a number of problems including the computer freezing up at random times including when he’s doing simple web browsing. When he tries to install software using the OpenSUSE software manager it asks for a DVD to be inserted even though there’s no optical drive. There’s no documentation for the OpenSUSE model. And the HP Toolbox device manager utility won’t open. And as I’ve previously noted, there’s no support for the OpenSUSE model on the HP web site.

I’m not particularly familiar with OpenSUSE, but if it’s package manager is anything like the one in Ubuntu, I’m guessing all you need to do is remove the DVD from the list of available repositories to solve that problem. But the freezups and problems with the Toolbox are not promising. And I’m still kind of disappointed to see that HP has no official support documents or downloads for this model.

If I can repartition the hard drive without destroying OpenSUSE, my first order of business may be to install Ubuntu, Windows XP, or another operating system. I’m a little bit wary of overwriting the default OS altogether, since there’s no guaranty that the drivers will be supported under the other operating systems.

All of which is to say, it’s starting to look like it might be worth spending the extra $50 to $100 to get the Vista model if you’re not an advanced computer user. And maybe even then.

Friday, April 18th, 2008 | Tags: , , ,